fbpx

Table Of Contents

How to Deal with Difficult Employees

How to Deal with Difficult Employees_ A Managers Complete Guide

Managing a team comes with its share of challenges, and perhaps none is more testing than handling difficult employees. Whether you’re a seasoned supervisor or a new manager, knowing how to address problematic workplace behaviors effectively can make the difference between a thriving team and a toxic environment. This comprehensive guide will equip you with practical strategies to transform challenging situations into opportunities for growth and development.

Consider this: According to recent workplace studies, managers spend an average of 25-40% of their time handling workplace conflicts and addressing challenging behavior. That’s more than 3 months per year dedicated to managing difficult situations rather than driving business growth. However, with the right approach and tools, you can significantly reduce this time while creating a more positive work environment.

Understanding the Root Causes of Difficult Behavior

Before implementing solutions, it’s crucial to understand what drives challenging workplace behavior. Often, what appears as difficulty might be a symptom of deeper issues. The key to effective management lies in identifying and addressing these underlying causes rather than just treating the surface-level symptoms.

  • Personal Challenges: External stressors, health issues, or family problems can manifest as workplace difficulties. An employee dealing with a family health crisis might become withdrawn or irritable, affecting their interactions with colleagues.
  • Professional Frustration: Unclear expectations, limited growth opportunities, or scheduling conflicts can lead to disengagement. For instance, an ambitious employee might become difficult if they feel overlooked for advancement opportunities.
  • Workplace Environment: Poor communication systems, inefficient processes, or team dynamics might contribute to problematic behavior. Something as fundamental as inconsistent scheduling can create stress that manifests as difficult behavior.

Essential Strategies for Supervisors Dealing with Difficult Employees

As a supervisor learning how to deal with difficult employees, your approach should be systematic and well-documented. The following framework has proven effective across various industries and situations, from retail to healthcare environments.

1. Document Everything Systematically

Maintain detailed records of incidents, conversations, and interventions. This documentation serves multiple purposes: it helps identify patterns, provides legal protection, and ensures fair treatment. Consider implementing digital solutions like Shyft to track attendance patterns, communication history, and performance metrics systematically.

Your documentation should include:

  • Dates and times of incidents
  • Detailed descriptions of behaviors and their impact
  • Witnesses or affected team members
  • Actions taken and outcomes
  • Follow-up plans and deadlines

2. Master the Art of Private Conversations

When addressing issues with difficult employees in the workplace, privacy is paramount. These conversations require careful planning and execution. Schedule one-on-one meetings in a neutral space, away from other team members. This approach shows respect and allows for more open dialogue about sensitive issues.

Structure your conversation using the following framework:

  • Opening: Start with a clear, professional tone that sets expectations for the discussion
  • Observation: Present specific examples of problematic behavior
  • Impact: Explain how these behaviors affect the team and business
  • Listen: Allow the employee to share their perspective
  • Solution: Collaborate on an action plan for improvement

3. Focus on Specific Behaviors and Outcomes

Instead of making general statements about an employee’s attitude, address specific actions and their impact on the team. This approach removes emotion from the equation and focuses on observable, measurable behaviors that can be improved.

For example, rather than saying “you’re always negative,” say “I’ve noticed you’ve expressed skepticism about our last three team initiatives without offering alternative solutions. This impacts team morale and our ability to implement improvements effectively.”

Leadership Strategies for New Managers

Learning how to deal with difficult employees as a new manager requires a delicate balance of authority and empathy. Your success depends on establishing clear boundaries while maintaining open lines of communication.

Build a foundation of clear expectations and consistent communication. Modern tools can help – for instance, using scheduling software for seamless shift management can prevent many conflicts before they arise. When employees have clarity about their schedules and responsibilities, many potential points of friction disappear.

Remember that employee satisfaction directly impacts performance. Sometimes, what appears as difficult behavior might be addressed through better workplace policies and systems. Consider implementing flexible scheduling options or creating clear paths for advancement to address underlying dissatisfaction.

HR Best Practices for Managing Difficult Situations

Human Resources plays a crucial role in addressing workplace challenges. A strong partnership between managers and HR can transform difficult situations into opportunities for organizational improvement. Here’s how HR can support managers and employees:

  • Clear Policies and Procedures: Develop and communicate clear behavioral expectations and consequences. These should be documented in employee handbooks and regularly reviewed during team meetings.
  • Comprehensive Training Programs: Provide regular management training on handling difficult situations, including conflict resolution, communication skills, and legal compliance.
  • Mediation Services: Offer neutral third-party intervention when needed, helping to resolve conflicts before they escalate into serious problems.

Creating an Action Plan for Improvement

When dealing with difficult employees at work, a structured improvement plan can transform challenging situations into success stories. This plan should be specific, measurable, and time-bound, with clear consequences for both success and failure to meet objectives.

  • Set Clear Goals: Establish specific, measurable objectives for improvement. For example, “Reduce customer complaints by 50% within 60 days” or “Complete all project deliverables on time for the next three months.”
  • Define Realistic Timelines: Create achievable deadlines for meeting these objectives, with regular check-ins to monitor progress and address challenges.
  • Provide Necessary Resources: Ensure employees have the tools, training, and support needed to succeed. This might include mentoring, additional training, or access to better technology solutions.

Preventing Future Challenges Through Proactive Management

Prevention is often more effective than intervention. By implementing proactive strategies, you can create an environment that minimizes difficult behaviors and promotes positive workplace interactions.

Focus on reducing employee turnover through improved workplace practices. Consider implementing flexible scheduling solutions like Shyft to accommodate employee needs while maintaining operational efficiency. When employees feel their needs are considered and respected, they’re less likely to exhibit difficult behaviors.

Create regular opportunities for feedback and communication. This might include:

  • Monthly one-on-one meetings with each team member
  • Anonymous suggestion boxes or feedback systems
  • Regular team building activities
  • Clear processes for addressing concerns before they escalate

Maintaining Professional Boundaries

As you work to improve difficult workplace situations, it’s crucial to maintain appropriate professional boundaries. This includes:

  • Keeping emotions in check during challenging conversations
  • Staying focused on workplace behaviors rather than personal issues
  • Following established procedures consistently
  • Documenting all significant interactions and decisions

Conclusion

Managing difficult employees requires patience, skill, and the right tools. By understanding root causes, implementing clear strategies, and maintaining professional documentation, you can transform challenging situations into opportunities for growth and improvement. Remember that every difficult situation presents an opportunity to strengthen your leadership skills and create a more positive workplace environment.

Ready to streamline your team management and reduce workplace friction? Try Shyft today and discover how better scheduling can lead to better team dynamics.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should I approach my first conversation with a difficult employee?

Start with a private, scheduled meeting in a neutral location. Focus on specific behaviors rather than personal characteristics, and come prepared with documented examples. Listen actively and work together to create an action plan for improvement. Remember to document the conversation and establish clear next steps.

What if an employee becomes defensive during feedback?

Remain calm and professional. Acknowledge their perspective while redirecting the conversation to specific behaviors and their impact on the workplace. Consider involving HR if the situation escalates or becomes unproductive. Sometimes, taking a short break and reconvening when emotions have cooled can lead to more productive discussions.

How long should I give an employee to improve their behavior?

The timeline depends on the severity of the issue and the employee’s role. Generally, set clear expectations with 30, 60, or 90-day improvement plans, documenting progress throughout. Regular check-ins help monitor improvement and adjust strategies as needed. Be sure to consider any relevant company policies or union agreements when establishing improvement timelines.

When should I involve HR in managing a difficult employee?

Involve HR early when dealing with serious behavioral issues, potential legal concerns, or if initial management interventions haven’t produced results. HR can provide guidance, documentation support, and ensure compliance with company policies and employment laws. They can also help design appropriate performance improvement plans and mediate complex situations.

How can I prevent difficult behavior from spreading through my team?

Address issues promptly and consistently to prevent a negative culture from developing. Maintain clear communication with all team members about expectations and consequences, while respecting confidentiality in individual cases. Regular team building activities and positive reinforcement of desired behaviors can help maintain a healthy workplace atmosphere.

author avatar
Brett Patrontasch CEO
Brett Patrontasch is the Co-founder and CEO of Shyft, an app that helps retail and service workers swap shifts and message each other.

Shyft Makes Scheduling Easy